Auto
Coverage for the cars and trucks your family drives every day.
Learn moreLocally owned since 1930
Independent Insurance
Agency in Defiance, Ohio
Home, auto, farm, life and business insurance from a locally owned agency in downtown Defiance, since 1930.
Meet the team at 414 Clinton Street.
Locally owned since 1930
Over 95 years in Defiance
Independent agency
Many insurance companies
Downtown Defiance
414 Clinton Street
Coverage
What would you like to protect?
Homeowners
Protection for your home, your belongings and your peace of mind.
Learn moreFarmowner
Coverage built around Northwest Ohio farms, homes and equipment.
Learn moreBusiness
Options for local businesses, from the storefront to the job site.
Learn moreAlso: Life · Renters · Watercraft · Motorcycle · Umbrella · All insurance products
Our team
Meet your local agents
President
Mike Menzel
Agency Principal
Kim Menzel
Insurance Specialist
Ashley Tettenhorst
Insurance Specialist
Amy Yenser
Insurance Specialist
Jeff Long
Our partners
Independent means more choices
We compare coverage from several insurance companies to help you find a policy that fits.
Reviews
What our clients say
“
I have used this insurance agency for years. The best broker is Amy. She does a great job with my contractors, auto, home and life insurance. She finds the best plans with the best rates. I highly recommend you stop in and get pricing.
James F.
Google review
“
Mike and staff have been very helpful and knowledgeable in all questions I've had and was able to get us a great rate on home and car insurance!
Amanda B.
Google review
“
Been a customer since I started driving. Wouldn't go anywhere else. Amazing customer service and local business is where it's at.
Paul F.
Google review
“
I have used them for insurance for over 10 years. I would recommend them to everyone. They treat me like family and are a joy to work with. I have all my insurance plans with them.
Ben D.
Google review
Blog
Insurance Insights
Agency
Why Work With an Independent Insurance Agency?
What "independent" means, and how it differs from buying from a single company.
Read more
Home
What Does Homeowners Insurance Cover in Ohio?
A plain-language guide to what Ohio homeowners insurance typically covers, common exclusions and questions to ask.
Read more
Auto
How Much Auto Insurance Do I Need in Ohio?
Ohio's minimum auto insurance requirements, and the coverage you may want for better protection.
Read moreFAQ
Questions? Let's start here.
If you don't see your question, call the office. A local agent will help you sort it out.
What does an independent agency do?
We represent several insurance companies, so we can compare their options with you instead of offering just one.
Where are you, and when are you open?
414 Clinton Street in downtown Defiance. Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday 8:30-4:00; Wednesday 8:30-noon; closed weekends.
How long has Roehrs-McMillen been around?
Over 95 years. We've been locally owned and operated since 1930.
Can I get covered online?
You can request a quote online. Coverage can't be started or changed through the website; we'll follow up with your quote, and you can call 419-784-3979 for immediate changes.
Talk to a local agent
Not sure what coverage you need?
Ask a local agent. We'll walk through your options with you.